Most bad engagements were visible in the pitch — here is what to look for.
Short answer: Only weakly. Ask instead for two references in your category and one client that left — and why.
Vanity-metric pitches
Decks built on impressions and "reach" with no mention of conversion, incrementality or baseline.
The same creator list for everyone
If the shortlist does not change materially with the brief, you are buying inventory, not strategy.
Opaque money
Refusal to separate retainer, creator fees and markup. You cannot manage what you cannot see.
No compliance position
An agency with no clear view on ASCI or FTC disclosure will eventually create a problem you inherit.
Junior account handling
The pitch team is senior; ask who actually runs the account and what else they carry.
Related reading
- Influencer marketing agency
- Questions to ask influencer marketing agency
- Influencer marketing agency brief
- Reels vs shorts vs tiktok
Frequently asked questions
Is a big client list a good signal?
Only weakly. Ask instead for two references in your category and one client that left — and why.
What if an agency guarantees ROI?
Treat it as a red flag unless the guarantee is contractually defined with a make-good. Most "guarantees" are marketing language.
Part of our complete guide: Influencer Marketing Agency: The Complete 2026 Guide