Skip to content
Hiring an Agency

How to Evaluate Influencer Marketing Agency Case Studies

Vanya Goel 1 min read

Case studies are marketing assets — read them for method, not for the headline number.

Short answer: Spend, creator count and tier, reach, engagement rate, and a business metric (trials, sales, CAC) against a stated baseline.

Look for the baseline

A campaign that "drove 2M views" means nothing without what the brand normally does. No baseline, no claim.

Look for the spend

Results without the budget behind them are unfalsifiable. Ask for spend and creator count.

Look for the mechanism

Which campaign type, which platform, which creator tier, and why. Method transfers; outcomes do not.

Look for the failure

Ask what they would change. Agencies that iterate describe changes specifically.

Frequently asked questions

What metrics should a good case study show?

Spend, creator count and tier, reach, engagement rate, and a business metric (trials, sales, CAC) against a stated baseline.

Are awards a useful signal?

Weakly. Awards reward creative, not efficiency. A boring campaign with strong incrementality is usually the better partner signal.

Part of our complete guide: Influencer Marketing Agency: The Complete 2026 Guide

More articles

All articles
Book a call