The answers to these separate agencies that run campaigns from agencies that resell creator inventory.
Short answer: "Show me a campaign that underperformed and what you changed." Agencies that cannot answer this either have not run enough campaigns or do not measure honestly.
On strategy
How would you approach our category? What would you not do? Which platform would you drop and why?
On creators
How do you build a shortlist? What is your vetting process for fake followers and brand safety? How many of these creators have you worked with before?
On money
What is the retainer, what is the markup, and what does the creator actually receive? Who owns the usage rights and for how long?
On measurement
What is your baseline? How do you separate influencer-driven lift from everything else running that month?
On the team
Who runs this day to day, and how many other accounts do they carry?
Related reading
- Influencer marketing agency
- Full service vs specialist influencer agency
- Influencer marketing agency cost
- Ugc marketing services
Frequently asked questions
What is the single most revealing question?
"Show me a campaign that underperformed and what you changed." Agencies that cannot answer this either have not run enough campaigns or do not measure honestly.
Should you ask for guaranteed results?
Guaranteed reach is reasonable. Guaranteed sales or follower growth is a red flag — no agency controls the algorithm or your product-market fit.
Part of our complete guide: Influencer Marketing Agency: The Complete 2026 Guide