Set the expectation before the campaign, because ROI arguments after the fact are unwinnable.
Short answer: For D2C performance campaigns, a blended CAC at or below your paid social CAC is a good outcome. For awareness, compare cost per engaged view against your video ad benchmarks.
Agree the metric first
Pick one primary metric — CAC, trials, revenue, or qualified leads — and agree the measurement window before launch.
Account for the halo
Creator campaigns lift branded search and direct traffic. If you attribute last-click only, you will systematically undervalue them.
Benchmark realistically
Awareness campaigns should be judged on cost per thousand engaged views; performance campaigns on CAC against your paid social baseline.
Judge on cycles, not posts
Single posts are noisy. Two campaign cycles is the minimum honest evaluation window.
Related reading
- Influencer marketing agency
- Influencer marketing agency brief
- Influencer marketing agency vs in-house
- Content marketing services
Frequently asked questions
What is a good ROI for influencer marketing?
For D2C performance campaigns, a blended CAC at or below your paid social CAC is a good outcome. For awareness, compare cost per engaged view against your video ad benchmarks.
How long before you can judge results?
Eight to twelve weeks, or two full campaign cycles. Judging after one post measures the creator, not the programme.
Part of our complete guide: Influencer Marketing Agency: The Complete 2026 Guide